Psychometric Ceiling Effects in the ZIP – When Love Does Not Differentiate

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Editors

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

IU Internationale Hochschule

Abstract

The German ZIP (Zufriedenheit in Paarbeziehungen) is an established seven-item measure of relationship satisfaction, but little is known about the item-level performance of its direct love item in highly satisfied samples. This exploratory post hoc study examined whether the ZIP love item shows a ceiling effect and whether a reduced six-item score excluding this item retains comparable psychometric properties. Data came from 685 German-speaking individuals in heterosexual romantic relationships lasting at least six months. Item descriptives, corrected item-rest correlations, internal consistency estimates, confirmatory factor analyses, and manifest score comparisons were used to compare the original seven-item ZIP (ZIP-7) with a reduced six-item variant (ZIP-6). The love item showed a severe ceiling effect: 94.31% of participants selected the maximum response category, with the highest mean (M = 4.92), lowest variability (SD = 0.35), strongest negative skewness (−4.80), and highest kurtosis (23.99) among all ZIP items. In the continuous-item ML CFA for ZIP-7, the love item had the lowest standardized factor loading (λ = .507), lowest explained variance (R² = .257), and highest standardized residual variance (θ = .743). The separate ML CFA for ZIP-6 yielded CFI = .987, TLI = .978, RMSEA = .067, and SRMR = .021. Cronbach’s alpha differed only slightly between ZIP-7 (α = .881) and ZIP-6 (α = .887). ZIP-7 and ZIP-6 were almost perfectly correlated, r =.997, and showed virtually identical associations with intimacy satisfaction, both rounded to r = .46. The findings support examining ZIP-6 as an exploratory sensitivity score requiring further validation, particularly in highly satisfied samples.

Description

Citation